I believe in the MLS.
No one is going to seriously argue the level of competition, fandom or style of play vs. a serious international soccer league.
I do think that the US has the best athletes in the world.
So in order to grow the league there has to be ground swell at grass roots. I think that's begun. However, there also has to be a national cognizance of the sport which I think is not so evident yet. YET! Yes, we're sending quite a few players to other leagues around the world and enjoying at least some modicum of success. What we need is to garner more interest in
OUR OWN leagues. I think the league is working on that with some fruit for their labor. The David Beckham experiment has been a success (unfortunately for the Galaxy, not in wins). And with new high profile involvement like Oscar de la Hoya's recent alliance with the Dynamo's ownership, I think things are headed in the right direction.
This is a slow process however and will need ample time for real penetration.
I have a theory on sports moving to mainstream and I'll be succinct as possible;
a. EXPOSURE (Why can you only use your feet?) - it always starts with exposure. Let me ask you this - 10 years ago how many motor sports would you see broadcast on big 4 TV (not cable)? Daytona and Indy pretty much, right? How about now? Now you may say the fandom grew so much there was a need for broadcast. I would say that's your chicken to my egg. Which leads to...
b. CASUAL INTEREST (What's all the brew-ha-ha?) - Once the sport has invaded your personal sports space you decide to take a cursory look to see what these idiots are so interested in. Before professional hockey came to Dallas (all apologies to the Dallas Blackhawks, Freeze and Ice of CHL fame) I really had no interest in hockey. We didn't play it in high school and there was no exposure (there's that word again) to it locally. But at my job where I was inundated with Boston expatriates (ex-patriots? hmmm) I was constantly hearing about hockey this and Ray Bourque that and "it's going to be a great weekend, I'm watching the Bruins/Whalers game with friends". What? Well, I decided to pick a random team and start following them so I could come in on Monday and say "yeh, but did you see what my Blackhawks did to the Canucks yesterday". It was fun. These were not the Dallas Blackhawks but Chicago. A city where I had never stepped foot. But I had a great time talking with the guys about it at the water cooler. By the end of the first season, I could even tell you the names of several starters and who was the best player on their checking line (whatever that was).
c. EXPERIENCED NOVICE? (I think that 4-4-2 means 2 forwards not defenders)- When I was in third grade my parents joined a bowling league and my options were to stay in the nursery with my 3 year old brother or join the junior bowling league. Hmmmm. "Do they have snacks in the nursery?" I didn't know anything about bowling except that the longer adults bowled the louder they got and it made them go to the bathroom about every other frame. But all things considered I decided to join the league. My first day of instruction a cute young girl with brown curly hair and a ball with her name
inside it says to me, "what's your high game".
"Huh".
"Have you never bowled before"?
"Oh sure, I thought you were talking about something else".
"My high game is 125, what's yours"?
"375".
I'm not sure if the look was "you're an idiot" or "he must bowl in the 'special league'".
At any rate, I ended up being a pretty good bowler after about a year and if you asked me what a 7-10 split was I could tell you. I knew where to line up on the lane to have the best chance of picking up the spare. I knew the advantages of having a lighter ball over a heavier ball for my size and strength. In other words, I knew just enough to make me dangerous and I would give you the "idiot" eye if you told me you bowled a 375.
d. IMMERSION (I can't believe we lost Kreis, he was our best scorer) - You start to have some knowledge of the game as a whole. Maybe you become a member of the Hoops Nation as I have (FC DALLAS). I also have 3 daughters that all play soccer and one plays for FC DALLAS Youth academy whose uniforms look exactly like the pro team. It's very cool. I watched my first MLS Superdraft the other day. Talk about exposure. I don't know many people who even knew it was televised. I bought a rebounder (no, not Shaq) for the kids to kick against in the yard. I bought a Fulham replica jersey, my first since graduating from CASUAL INTEREST guy. I can't seem to get enough of everything soccer.
e. FAN (So and so is good but he's no Johnny Haynes. Hey, you remember when...) - I am a huge football fan. NFL, College, High School, you name it. I begin studying the NFL draft in late November and it doesn't take place until the end of April. I will go and watch a game between two high schools that my kids don't go to, just because it's a big rivalry. I really love the sport and have a better than average understanding of it from a tactical standpoint. I love the history of the game. The old guys wearing leather helmets and the oddly oversized wool pants with the pads sewn inside them. The underlying theme here is history tied to the present and predicating the future. They're all connected to the fan.
This is why the MLS will never be a truly accepted fan favorite sport until these factors come to pass and there is a heritage of fans. That can only be accomplished with time and history in perspective of the present. The MLS will get there if they concentrate on A through C. Then D and E will happen.